Proof Over Pedigree: Why Today’s VCs Care More About Your Traction Than Your Résumé
The way startups get funding is changing fast. Not long ago, a founder’s pedigree—where you went to school, where you worked, and who you knew—could practically guarantee a meeting (and maybe even a check). But those days are fading. Now, what really matters is your proof—evidence that your business works, customers care, and you can actually get things done.
Let’s dig into what’s changed, why it matters, and what founders should focus on now.
The Traditional Pedigree Premium
Before the shift, pedigree was king in venture capital. VCs are notoriously busy and review an overwhelming number of startup pitches every year. The fastest way to filter all that noise? Look for familiar logos and top-tier schools on founders’ résumés.
If your LinkedIn boasted experience at places like Google, Y Combinator, or Stanford, doors opened wider. The logic seemed sound—if you’ve succeeded before, or thrived in elite environments, you probably know what you’re doing. But this shortcut led to a pretty homogenous startup world. It also meant a lot of ambitious, scrappy founders were left out simply because they lacked the "right" connections or credentials.
The bias toward pedigree had real consequences:
- Missed opportunities in overlooked markets.
- Fewer women, minority, or first-generation founders getting funded.
- An ecosystem that often placed potential over performance.
The Rise of Traction: What Investors Want Today
Recently, everything’s changed. The market is tougher, capital is tighter, and LPs (Venture Capital’s investors) want results—not just promises. For today’s VC, what truly matters is traction.
But what does traction actually mean?
Traction is real-world validation. It’s proof that your startup is headed in the right direction, and that customers, users, or markets actually care about what you’re building. This can show up as:
- Revenue and real sales
- Growing user numbers
- Customer retention (not just sign-ups, but people coming back)
- Media coverage or industry buzz
- Strategic partnerships, strong advisory boards, or powerful hires
Traction transforms your pitch from “here’s what I think might work” to “here’s what is already working.” And that’s something investors can’t ignore.
Why the Shift? What’s Driving Traction-First Thinking?
Let’s look at why so many VCs are prioritizing proof over pedigree.
1. Economic Uncertainty
The last few years have taught everyone—investors included—that market optimism doesn’t last forever. With more money at risk and exits taking longer, VCs aren’t willing to rely just on gut feel or Ivy League diplomas. They want evidence that you know how to get—and keep—customers, especially in shaky markets.
2. Bias Busting
There’s growing recognition that pedigree is often just code for privilege. You don’t need to look hard to find groundbreaking companies launched by founders with average résumés. By shifting to traction, VCs can spot great businesses wherever they come from—rural towns, immigrant backgrounds, or non-traditional career paths.
3. Proof of Execution
It’s easy to talk the talk; traction proves you can walk the walk. Building even a small user base, landing that first paying customer, or getting a product into the hands of real people is tough. Founders who pull it off have demonstrated a critical skill: they can execute despite obstacles.
4. Learning from Mistakes
Some of the “safest” pedigree bets have turned into the biggest startup flops. Investors have learned (sometimes the hard way) that impressive credentials don’t always translate into results. On the other hand, gritty operators—no matter their background—often outperform.
How VCs Are Rethinking Their Process
This isn't just talk. Venture firms are actively changing how they evaluate deals.
-
Blind evaluations: More investors are exploring “blind” reviews—instead of seeing a founder’s name, school, or background, they focus just on the idea, market, and evidence. This minimizes unconscious bias and spotlights the startup’s fundamentals.
-
Qualitative and quantitative proof: Traction isn’t only about Excel spreadsheets. It also means showing smart experiments, creative marketing, or building a passionate (even small) user base. VCs are looking at how founders try stuff, learn quickly, and adapt—regardless of headline metrics.
-
Concept-first investing: Some investors, like Ascend Venture Capital, now start by reviewing the business concept and early evidence of demand before caring who is behind the product.
-
Valuing story: Not every founder has a billion-dollar exit or Fortune 500 on their résumé, but every founder can have a compelling story: Why you? Why this problem? Why now? Investors want to know what gives you unique insight or grit to tackle your market.
What This Means for Founders
If you’ve felt like your résumé is “not enough,” you’re not alone. The good news? In today’s landscape, you can compete—and win—on merit. Here’s how:
1. Focus on Revealing Real Demand
Even the scrappiest prototype, validated by real customers or engaged users, will beat a polished pitch deck every time. Free trials, pilots, or letters of intent from buyers can punch above their weight.
2. Make Your Metrics Your Allies
Don’t just throw business jargon around. Track growth, retention, conversion, or engagement—with simple graphs, not just “vanity” numbers like downloads. Highlight when people pay, use, return, or stick around for your product.
3. Build Faster Than You “Network”
Networking is great, but product comes first. Instead of chasing intros to fancy investors, chase down your next user or sale. Results will get VCs knocking on your door—regardless of who you know.
4. Tell Your Unique Story
If you’re an outsider, lean in: explain how your background helps you see things differently or hustle harder. Investors are increasingly attracted to novel perspectives and underdog founders who know their market better than anyone else.
5. Assemble a Strong Team
Even if you haven’t “done it before,” if you can recruit team members or advisors who strengthen your company, that’s itself a form of traction. Investors notice when sharp people want to work with you, even before you raise serious money.
Why This Is Good for the Startup Ecosystem
A proof-over-pedigree venture world is a more meritocratic, diverse, and resilient one. When investors seek out evidence rather than echoing last year’s top résumés, funds flow to the most promising founders—regardless of where they came from. That means:
- More inclusive opportunities for women, minorities, immigrants, and anyone outside Silicon Valley’s bubble.
- More creative, differentiated companies tackling overlooked problems.
- Stronger, more robust returns for VCs willing to dig below the obvious.
The New VC Checklist
For founders ready to impress the new breed of investor, here’s a quick litmus test:
- Do you have paying customers, active users, or some form of market validation?
- Can you show evidence that your product solves a real pain—not just in theory, but in practice?
- Does your team’s composition suggest you can execute, adapt, and learn quickly?
- Are you making visible progress each month—not just talking about your vision, but showing traction?
If you can answer yes—even to some of these—you’re in a great spot, no matter what your résumé says.
The modern VC world is far from perfect, but it’s evolving. Proof is winning out over pedigree as the key to getting funded. So whether you’re an outsider, an underdog, or just someone who likes to build stuff that works, your time has never been better.
Time to show, not just tell.
